Custom Cake Flavor Menu
Signature Cake Pairings
Our best selling cake with a moist, light, melt-in-your-mouth texture.
Fave buttercream pairings: chocolate, lemon
This rainbow sprinkle-filled cake is popular with kids and adults alike! This cake evokes memories for many people.
Fave buttercream pairings: old-fashioned vanilla, oreo, strawberry
- Vanilla Chocolate Chip
Mini chocolate chips are baked into this yummy batter.
Fave buttercream pairings: truffle cream, Nutella, raspberry
- Red Velvet
Our red velvet cake cake is made with lots of cocoa and buttermilk, giving it a beautiful depth of flavor and deep mahogany hue.
We almost always match this up with our old fashioned vanilla buttercream!
- Chocolate Midnight
Our devil's food cake is chocolatey and moist, and made with plenty of cocoa and pure Belgian chocolate. Our secret is adding coffee to the batter to amp up the rich chocolate flavor!
Fave buttercream pairings: salted caramel, peanut butter, oreo, orange
Our carrot cake has fresh grated carrots, crushed pineapple and toasted coconut baked right into the batter, making this cake super-moist.
Fave pairings: ginger cream cheese icing (late fall/winter) or old fashioned vanilla
Premium Cake Pairings
*Our premium cake flavors are available for 8" diameter or larger custom-designed and tiered cakes (30+ servings).
Our champagne cake has a delicate crumb and flecks of orange zest. It is perfect for bridal showers, weddings and special birthday cakes.
Fave buttercream pairings: strawberry, orange, lemon raspberry
- Lemon Thyme*
A gorgeous lemon cake baked with a hint of fresh thyme in the batter.
Fave buttercream pairings: lemon, strawberry, raspberry
Fluffy almond-scented cake perfect for marzipan lovers!
Fave buttercream pairings: orange, truffle cream, raspberry
- Brown Sugar Banana*
Decadent and full of rich banana goodness and spice.
Fave buttercream pairings: Nutella, truffle cream, salted caramel
Delicately spiced white cake that has distinctive a floral/citrus edge.
Fave buttercream pairings: espresso, orange, salted caramel
- Pumpkin Spice (Fall/Winter)
Velvety, moist pumpkin cake accented with warm spices.
Fave buttercream pairings: espresso, salted caramel, old fashioned vanilla, ginger cream cheese icing (late fall/winter)
- Coconut* (Spring/Summer)
This fragrant cake is made with real coconut and coconut milk, and has a lovely tropical flavor. A refreshing option in the spring and summer!
Fave buttercream pairings: old fashioned vanilla, lemon, raspberry, chocolate
- Earl Grey Tea Cake*
Unique, delicate cake flavored with Earl Grey tea and lavender - Beautiful for spring or summer weddings.
Fave buttercream pairings: orange, lemon, strawberry, salted caramel
Workshop Flavor Pairings
* Adventurous, sophisticated flavors available for larger, custom-designed and tiered cakes (20+ servings).
- Breakfast on the Thames*
Earl Grey tea cake / orange buttercream / honey drizzle
- Sunshine & Thyme*
Lemon-thyme cake / tart lemon curd / lemon meringue buttercream
- Winter Pines*
Fluffy almond cake / rosemary caramel / salted caramel meringue buttercream (fall/winter)
- Scandinavian Coffee Break*
Cardamom cake / chocolate espresso crunch / espresso meringue buttercream
- Chocolate Orange*
Vanilla chocolate chip cake / pure Belgian ganache / orange meringue buttercream
- Bananas Foster*
Brown sugar banana cake / caramelized banana spread / cinnamon meringue buttercream
- Peanut Butter Whiskey Caramel*
Chocolate stout cake / whiskey caramel / peanut butter meringue buttercream